Microclimate map · Vinton, Traer, Dysart, La Porte City, Van Horne, Garrison, Keystone, Mount Auburn, Brandon, Clutier

Fruit Trees for Vinton, Traer, Dysart, La Porte City and Van Horne, Iowa

On January 31, 2019, the Vinton station read −35°F, its coldest in 72 years on file, while Belle Plaine read −33°F. Downtown Vinton plans for −33°F, and this map shows where the ground around it runs warmer and colder for fruit.

On January 16, 2009, the Belle Plaine station, just south of this map, read −38°F, the coldest in its 120 years of records. Vinton read −34°F that morning. Ten years later, on January 31, 2019, Vinton bottomed out at −35°F and Belle Plaine read −33°F. So for fruit trees in Vinton, Traer, Dysart, La Porte City and Van Horne I'd start with hardiness, because every town here plans for −30°F to −35°F.

But this flat country still sorts the cold. The whole map spans under 300 feet, and the Cedar River bottom north of La Porte City plans for −36°F while the hillside west of Traer plans for −28°F. On a still night at bloom the valley walls above the Cedar read 12°F warmer than downtown Vinton and the river bottom just north of town reads 6°F colder.

The map follows the Cedar down from La Porte City past Mount Auburn to Vinton, with Brandon off to the east. Then it runs west across the Tama County line to Dysart, Traer, Buckingham and Voorhies, and south to Garrison, Van Horne, Keystone, Newhall, Elberon, Clutier, Vining and Gladstone. That's most of Benton County, the east side of Tama County and a corner each of Black Hawk and Buchanan counties. Put your address in the search box on the map and you'll get the number for your own ground, and the list of what we sell that has come through it.

How to read this map

Each number on the map is a 30-year planning low. That's the night that comes around about once in 30 years, the same number our cold hardiness calculator gives, nudged for the lay of the land. It's a safe line to plan a tree around. It isn't the record. Click any spot and you also get its MFTC zone (that number in half zones), its typical winter (an ordinary year's coldest night, the kind of number USDA's zones come from) and its spring reading, which is how much warmer or colder it runs than downtown Vinton on a still, clear night at bloom.

I use downtown Vinton as the reference. It sits on the Cedar River bottom at 788 feet and plans for −33°F, MFTC zone 3b, with a typical winter of −17°F. The middle of the growing ground plans for −32°F (zone 3b). Half of it falls between −33°F and −31°F and nine tenths between −34°F and −30°F, so every town on the map lands in the same MFTC zone. The ground itself runs from 760 feet to 1,054 feet. The two ends:

  • Hillside 1.7 miles west-northwest of Traer: −28°F (MFTC 4a), the mildest spot
  • Van Horne, the mildest town: −30°F
  • Brandon: −35°F
  • Cedar bottom 2.2 miles north of La Porte City: −36°F (zone 3a), the coldest ground on the map

The spring layer spreads a lot wider. The towns stay close, from Buckingham, 0.3°F colder than downtown Vinton on a bloom night, to Elberon, 6.8°F warmer. But the river and creek bottoms read 4°F to 9°F colder than downtown and the valley walls and high ground 9°F to 14°F warmer. So I'd let the winter number pick the varieties and the spring reading pick the spot.

Why the map looks the way it does

This is what the Iowa Geological Survey calls the Iowan Erosion Surface. It's old glacial till plains cut up by erosion, with sand sheets, dunes and long loess-capped ridges called paha lined up northwest to southeast. The 1922 soil survey of Benton County put the county's whole range of relief at not much over 200 feet, with the paha standing 60 to 80 feet above the plain and a wind-shaped sandy belt 2 to 4 miles wide along the north side of the Cedar. On our map the low point, 760 feet, is the Cedar bottom 2.7 miles east of Vinton. The high point, 1,054 feet, is just north of Wolf Creek.

Two valleys carry the cold. The Cedar comes down from the northwest past La Porte City, runs southeast past Mount Auburn to Vinton and turns east out of the map. Wolf Creek runs east from Traer, several miles north of Dysart, down to La Porte City. On a clear, calm night the ground loses its heat to the sky and the air lying on it chills, and that heavier air runs downhill and pools in the low spots. Here that means the Cedar bottoms, the Wolf Creek valley, the smaller creek bottoms and the closed low spots on the upland, which the Geological Survey maps with seasonal high water tables. And there's no big lake to soften any of it.

With so little relief the towns nearly all sit down in the cold pool, none more than 80 feet above its local floor and most on slopes of 3 percent or less. The valleys are where you see the difference, and you see it most on spring nights. At Vinton the Cedar bottom just north of town and the valley wall northwest of it, 160 feet up, are 5°F apart in winter and 18°F apart on the same spring night.

North of Dysart a smaller creek does the same thing:

  • Its bottom, 2.3 miles out: −34°F, 4.5°F colder than downtown Vinton at bloom
  • The hillside two thirds of a mile past it, 110 feet up: −30°F, 8°F warmer

That sorting only works on calm, clear nights. When a deep arctic air mass settles over Iowa it covers hilltop and bottom alike. It did on February 3, 1996, when the Belle Plaine station read −35°F, Toledo 3N −34°F and Vinton −30°F. So I'd pick a variety that's hardy enough first and then use the site to help it.

Vinton and Garrison

Vinton, the Benton County seat, was founded in 1849 and first platted as Fremont. An old county history put it on a high bottom on the Cedar's south bank, with prairie rising to the south and timber nearly two miles wide across the river. Our downtown point is the Benton County Courthouse, built in 1906.

Downtown Vinton plans for −33°F, MFTC zone 3b, with a typical winter of −17°F, and within 3 miles the ground runs from −35°F to −30°F. The cold side is the river. The Cedar flooded parts of Vinton in 2008, too, so I think that ground is a poor bet for trees on two counts. Here's how it lays out, with the bloom night reading against downtown:

  • Cedar bottom 1.3 miles north-northeast: −35°F, 6°F colder
  • Bottom 1.3 miles southeast: −34°F, 5°F colder
  • Slope 1.8 miles west of downtown: −32°F, 5°F warmer
  • Hillside 2.6 miles east-southeast: −31°F, 12°F warmer
  • Hillside 2.8 miles northwest, 160 feet above its floor: −30°F (MFTC 4a), 12°F warmer

I'd put apricots, plums and sweet cherries on those slopes. The river bottom is apple, applecrab and bush fruit ground.

Garrison, 6.4 miles west-southwest of Vinton, is where the Old Creamery Theatre got its start in 1971. It sits on the toe of the slope at 880 feet and plans for −34°F (MFTC 3b), typical winter −18°F, and reads 1.4°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. The low ground half a mile southeast plans for −35°F and reads 6°F colder. I'd put the fruit on the benches. The one 2.3 miles north-northwest, 160 feet above its floor, plans for −30°F (MFTC 4a) and reads 11°F warmer than downtown Vinton, and the one 2.8 miles south-southeast −29°F and 9.5°F warmer.

La Porte City, Brandon and Mount Auburn

Up the Cedar to the north, La Porte City, in the Black Hawk County corner, sits on the valley floor at 831 feet with Wolf Creek coming down to it from the west. It plans for −33°F (MFTC 3b), typical winter −18°F, and reads 2.3°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. Around it:

  • Cedar bottom 2.2 miles north of town: −36°F (MFTC 3a), the coldest ground on the map, 5°F colder than downtown Vinton
  • Wolf Creek bottom 2.3 miles southwest: −35°F, 7.4°F colder, one of the coldest spring readings on the map
  • Bench 1.5 miles west of town, 130 feet up: −31°F, 7°F warmer

That bench is the best ground close in. North of the map, toward Waterloo, see our Waterloo and Cedar Falls map.

Brandon, over the Buchanan County line, has been home to Iowa's largest frying pan since 2004. It's also the coldest town on the map. It's on the valley floor just 10 feet above its floor and plans for −35°F, MFTC zone 3b by a hair, with a typical winter of −19°F, and reads 0.4°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. The low ground just south of town plans for −35°F (zone 3a) and reads 4.6°F colder. But the hillside 2.9 miles south, 150 feet up above the Cedar, plans for −31°F and reads 11°F warmer.

Mount Auburn, platted in 1871, sits west of the Cedar at 878 feet, 80 feet above its floor. It plans for −31°F, typical winter −16°F, and reads 3.5°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. The river bottom 3 miles southeast plans for −34°F. The hillside 1.9 miles north-northeast, 110 feet up, plans for −30°F and reads 7°F warmer.

Dysart and Eagle Center

Dysart was platted in 1872 on the Burlington, Cedar Rapids and Northern and named for a farmer, Joseph Dysart. It sits up on the flat at 974 feet on the Tama County side of the line, and the 1922 soil survey put Benton County's highest ground near Dysart, at 968 feet. Dysart plans for −31°F, MFTC zone 3b, with a typical winter of −16°F, and reads 2.4°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. Within 3 miles the planning low runs from −34°F in the creek bottom north of town to −30°F on the hillside past it.

Farther north the land drops to Wolf Creek. Its bottom, about 6 miles north of Dysart, plans for −35°F and reads 4.4°F colder than downtown Vinton. Right above it on the north side is the top of the map, 1,054 feet and 200 feet above its floor. It plans for −31°F and reads 13°F warmer than downtown Vinton on a bloom night. That's about as good a spring reading as this map gives.

Eagle Center is a hamlet near the north edge, on the toe of the slope at 960 feet. It plans for −31°F, typical winter −17°F, and reads 3.6°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. The valley floor 2.6 miles east plans for −34°F and reads 3.6°F colder.

Traer, Buckingham and Voorhies

Traer was laid out in 1873 on the same railroad, on the south bank of Wolf Creek. Its landmarks include a freestanding iron spiral staircase, a Carnegie library and the Wilson Nature Preserve. The town sits on the valley floor at 913 feet and plans for −32°F (MFTC 3b), with a typical winter of −18°F, and reads 1°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom.

Traer has the mildest ground on the map right next door. The hillside 1.7 miles west-northwest of town sits 140 feet above its floor on a 9 percent slope. It plans for −28°F, MFTC zone 4a, with a typical winter of −14°F, and reads 12°F warmer than downtown Vinton on a bloom night. Then the bottoms:

  • Wolf Creek bottom 0.6 miles northeast: −33°F, 4°F colder
  • Bottom 1.7 miles south-southeast: −33°F, 5°F colder

That's 5°F apart in winter and 17°F apart at bloom, all within 2 miles of town. If I had a say in where the trees go in Traer, I'd go west and up.

Buckingham, 4.9 miles north of Traer, sits on the valley floor only 10 feet above its floor. It plans for −33°F and reads 0.3°F colder than downtown Vinton at bloom, the coldest spring reading of any named place. The hillside 0.7 miles southwest, 100 feet up, plans for −30°F and reads 10°F warmer. Up in the northwest corner Voorhies plans for −31°F, and the ground half a mile south of it −29°F (MFTC 4a).

Clutier, Elberon, Vining and Gladstone

South of Traer the Tama County side rolls a little more. Clutier sits on the valley floor at 873 feet and plans for −32°F (MFTC 3b), typical winter −17°F, and reads 0.2°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. The creek bottom 0.4 miles south-southeast plans for −33°F and reads 3°F colder. West of town is some of the best fruit ground on the map. The hillside 1.5 miles west, 130 feet above its floor, plans for −29°F (MFTC 4a) and reads 11°F warmer at bloom.

Elberon and Vining are the two places on the map that sit on real hillsides, and you can see it in spring. Elberon is 60 feet above its floor on an 8 percent slope. It plans for −32°F and reads 6.8°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom, the best spring reading of any named place, while the creek bottom 0.6 miles west reads 5.7°F colder.

Vining is 3.5 miles west-southwest on a 6 percent slope. It plans for −32°F and reads 5.8°F warmer. Around it:

  • Bench 1.5 miles west, 130 feet up: −29°F (MFTC 4a), 11°F warmer
  • Draw 2.2 miles east: −33°F, 5°F colder

Gladstone, down in the southwest corner at 852 feet, plans for −31°F, typical winter −16°F, and reads 3.2°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. The hillside 2.8 miles north-northeast of it, 150 feet up, plans for −29°F and reads 11°F warmer. Toward Toledo, Tama and Marshalltown, our Marshalltown, Grinnell and the Iowa River map picks up.

Van Horne, Keystone and Newhall

Van Horne, Keystone and Newhall, south of the Cedar, share the Benton Community school district with Elberon. Van Horne, at 948 feet, is the mildest town on the map. It plans for −30°F, MFTC zone 3b right at the line with 4a, with a typical winter of −15°F, and reads 1.8°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. Three miles north of town the valley floor plans for −33°F.

Keystone, platted in 1881, sits 5.5 miles west of Van Horne on the toe of the slope at 892 feet. It plans for −34°F (MFTC 3b), typical winter −18°F, and reads 1.9°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. The creek bottom half a mile south-southeast plans for −33°F and reads 4.8°F colder than downtown.

Newhall, on the east edge of the map at 880 feet, plans for −32°F, typical winter −16°F, and reads 1.5°F warmer than downtown Vinton at bloom. The bottom 0.7 miles west reads 3°F colder. The hillside 1.4 miles south-southeast, 110 feet up on a 7 percent slope, plans for −29°F (MFTC 4a) and reads 9°F warmer. Toward Cedar Rapids, the Cedar Rapids and Iowa City map takes over.

Spring frost and bloom around Vinton

The Vinton station's median last 32°F frost, 1991 to 2020, is April 27, and its median first frost in fall is October 8, a frost free season of 163 days. The station sits 1.6 miles from downtown and our spring layer reads its spot about even with downtown. So I'd trust those dates for town. Not for the bottoms.

On a still, clear night in spring the map spreads more than 20°F from the coldest bottom to the warmest slope. The cold readings, 4°F to 9°F colder than downtown Vinton, are all in river and creek bottoms: the Wolf Creek bottom southwest of La Porte City, the low ground by Garrison, the Cedar bottoms north of Vinton and the creek bottoms by Elberon, Traer and Dysart.

The warm ones run 11°F to 14°F warmer and sit on valley walls and hillsides 100 to 200 feet above their floors. That's the high ground north of Wolf Creek, the slopes west of Traer, Elberon and Clutier, the valley walls northwest and east-southeast of Vinton, and the hillside south of Brandon.

Apricots bloom first, so I'd give them the highest slope you've got with open ground below for the cold to drain into. Peaches, plums and sweet cherries come next. Pears bloom early too and I wouldn't put them in the low spots. Apples, applecrabs and bush fruit handle lower ground. Stay out of the closed low spots on the upland. And check what's downhill of your trees, because a shelterbelt, a hedge or a road grade across the slope holds the cold back against them. Leave an opening at the bottom.

What the weather records say

The coldest reading in the long station records around this map is the Belle Plaine station's −38°F on January 16, 2009, when Vinton read −34°F. The Toledo 3N station, just west of the map, has 127 years on file. A few other cold days:

  • February 3, 1996: Toledo 3N −34°F, its coldest
  • March 1, 1962: Vinton −34°F, Toledo 3N −31°F
  • January 12, 1912: Belle Plaine and Toledo 3N both −31°F, the day Washta set Iowa's state record of −47°F

The Vinton station, at 796 feet, is the one inside the map. In 31 winters since 1995-96 its coldest is −35°F (2018-19) and its average winter low −18°F. Its 1-in-30 number is −34°F, the same as the map gives at the station. Over 72 years its average yearly low is −19°F.

Bad winters can beat the planning low. The Vinton station's −35°F on January 31, 2019 went 1°F past what the map plans for at the station and 2°F past downtown's −33°F, and Belle Plaine's −38°F in 2009 went further still. The planning low is a line to plan around, not a ceiling on the cold, so on low ground we'd go with the hardier half of any list and keep trees that sit right at their rating up on the slopes.

USDA's 2023 map puts Vinton (52349), Traer (50675), Dysart (52224), La Porte City (50651) and Keystone (52249) in zone 5a, −20°F to −15°F. USDA works from an average winter's coldest night, close to our typical winter, which runs −15°F to −19°F in the towns on this map. I'd rather plan for the bad night. On our map that's MFTC zone 3b in every town, 3a in the coldest Cedar bottoms and the low ground at Brandon, and 4a on the best hillsides west of Traer, Clutier and Vining and the valley wall northwest of Vinton. It's a zone and a half colder than USDA's number for the same towns.

What you can grow here

The winter number does most of the sorting on this map, and the window is narrow. Anything we sell rated −40°F or colder has come through colder than every planning low here. Anything rated −35°F has come through every town, though at Brandon it's right at the line. The −30°F trees fit only the best hillsides. And nothing we sell rated −25°F or milder fits anywhere on this map, so Stella cherry, Glohaven peach, Hardired nectarine, the −20°F trees and Chicago Hardy Fig are out.

The best hillsides and benches, and Van Horne, −28°F to −30°F

This is the hillside west of Traer (−28°F), the slopes west of Clutier and Vining, north of Gladstone and south of Newhall, and the bench south of Garrison (−29°F). Then Van Horne, the valley wall northwest of Vinton, the bench north of Garrison and the hillside north of Dysart (−30°F). Everything rated −35°F or colder has come through this with room to spare. The −30°F trees have too, with 1°F to 2°F to spare at −28°F to −29°F and right at the line at −30°F, so I'd give them your warmest, best drained corner.

Vinton, Traer, Dysart and most of the map, −31°F to −34°F

That's downtown Vinton, Traer, Dysart, La Porte City, Mount Auburn, Eagle Center, Voorhies, Gladstone, Clutier, Elberon, Vining, Newhall and Buckingham (−31°F to −33°F), and Garrison and Keystone (−34°F). Everything rated −35°F or colder has come through all of it. At Garrison and Keystone that's only 1°F to spare, so I'd give the −35°F trees your best spot there. The −30°F trees haven't come through this. Leave them for the hillsides.

Brandon and the Cedar and Wolf Creek bottoms, −35°F to −36°F

This is Brandon and the low ground south of it, the Cedar bottoms north of Vinton and around La Porte City, the Wolf Creek bottom north of Dysart and the low ground by Garrison (−35°F), and the Cedar bottom north of La Porte City (−36°F). The −35°F trees are right at the line at −35°F and haven't come through −36°F, so I'd stick to −40°F and colder here. The bottoms also read 4°F to 7°F colder than downtown Vinton at bloom, so lean on apples, applecrabs and bush fruit.

Pears and plums like Summercrisp, Ure, Toka and Mount Royal (all −45°F) have the hardiness for this ground. But they bloom early, so give them the highest corner of the lot.

Matching trees to the spring layer

If your spot reads at or above downtown Vinton on the spring layer, I'd use it for apricots, peaches, plums and sweet cherries. If it reads 3°F or more below (the Cedar and Wolf Creek bottoms and the creek bottoms by Traer, Dysart, Elberon, Keystone and Garrison), give it to apples, applecrabs and bush fruit. Most apples, pears and plums want a second variety in bloom at the same time, and our pollination maps show which ones pair up.

Soil, site and roots

I'd plant on a slope, off the floor, in full sun. The side of a paha or the edge of the upland, not the bottom or a closed low spot, and keep trees off the Cedar floodplain. Sandy ground like the belt north of the Cedar dries out fast, so young trees there want steady water. Test the drainage before a tree goes in. Fill the hole, let it empty and fill it again, and if there's still water in it the next morning, build a low mound or move the tree. Drip is the only way I'd water fruit trees. White water-based latex paint on young trunks heads off sunscald. And a guard of 1/4 inch hardware cloth, at least 2 feet tall and pushed 2 to 3 inches into the soil, keeps voles off the bark.

Fruit history here

Fruit has been part of farm life here a long time. The 1922 soil survey of Benton County found fruit on nearly every farm, though none of it was grown commercially. Apples came first, then cherries, plums, pears and peaches. The county had 31,042 apple trees in 1919 and they bore 15,072 bushels. Farming runs deep around Traer too, where James "Tama Jim" Wilson, U.S. Secretary of Agriculture, lived.

Wine came later. Dave and Mary Paustian's winery between Vinton and Shellsburg, near the east edge of the map, was the first in Benton County, and as of 2021 it grew its own grapes. Marquette and Frontenac (both −35°F) and La Crescent grape (−40°F) have come through colder than downtown Vinton plans for. We didn't find a u-pick orchard or cidery inside the map. The nearest listed are Allens Orchard at Marion and The Big Apple Orchard at Mount Vernon. In town there's the Vinton Parks and Recreation Farmers Market.

Questions people ask

When is the last frost in Vinton?

The Vinton station's median last 32°F frost, 1991 to 2020, is April 27, and its median first fall frost is October 8, a frost free season of 163 days. The Cedar bottoms around town read 5°F to 6°F colder than downtown on a still spring night, so I'd plant early bloomers on higher ground.

What growing zone is Vinton, Iowa?

USDA's 2023 map puts Vinton's 52349 ZIP code in zone 5a, −20°F to −15°F, built on an average winter's coldest night. Our map has downtown Vinton planning for −33°F, MFTC zone 3b, with a typical winter of −17°F. The valley wall northwest of town plans for −30°F (MFTC 4a) and the Cedar bottom just north of town −35°F.

Can you grow peaches in Vinton?

Yes, the hardiest one. Downtown plans for −33°F and Siberian C peach has come through −35°F. Contender, Blushingstar and Veteran (−30°F) fit only the best hillsides, like the slopes west of Traer and Clutier (−28°F to −29°F). Either way I'd plant peaches on a slope that reads warm on the spring layer, not in the Cedar bottom.

Where are the frost pockets around Vinton?

The river and creek bottoms. On a still bloom night the Cedar bottom just north of Vinton and the low ground by Garrison read 6°F colder than downtown, the Wolf Creek bottom southwest of La Porte City 7°F colder, and the bottoms by Traer and north of Dysart 4°F to 5°F colder. In winter the coldest ground is the Cedar bottom north of La Porte City, at −36°F.

What growing zone are Traer and Dysart in?

USDA's 2023 map puts Traer (50675) and Dysart (52224) in zone 5a. On our map Traer plans for −32°F and Dysart −31°F, both MFTC zone 3b, with typical winters of −18°F and −16°F. The hillside 1.7 miles west-northwest of Traer plans for −28°F, MFTC zone 4a, the mildest ground on the map.

What fruit trees grow in La Porte City?

La Porte City plans for −33°F, so anything rated −35°F or colder has come through it. I'd look at Siberian C peach, Lapins sweet cherry, Superior plum with Toka as its pollenizer, Hardy Iowa apricot, and apples like Liberty and Haralson. On the −36°F Cedar bottom north of town I'd stick to −40°F trees and colder.

Warmer spots, colder spots

Here's what to plan for at named places on the map, warmest first. Each one is the 1-in-30-year low for that spot. It's the cold hardiness calculator's number off the same weather stations, and then our microclimate model sharpens it for the ground right there. Zone means our MFTC zone, and that comes from the one bad night, not an average.

Runs warmer

    Runs colder

      How this map works

      Every number on this map is a 30-year planning low, same as our cold hardiness calculator gives you. I build it from NOAA station records and lean it a little cold on purpose, then nudge it a degree or two for the ground right around you. The spring frost layer runs our whole terrain model, which follows cold air down the draws and into the bottoms. Plan with it but don't treat it like a promise. How long the cold hangs on matters, so do wind and soil and those warm spells in late winter.

      If you want the physics of cold air, how I build the number, every terrain weight and where the model falls short, it's all on one page: how our microclimate maps work.

      The weather stations behind it

      These are the long record stations in and around this map, with each one's own numbers since the winter of 1995-96. The last column is the map's 30-year number right at the station. It won't match the station exactly, because it's a blend of the stations around it. That's how the calculator does it everywhere.

      Station Elev (ft) Winters Coldest since 1995 Average winter low 1-in-30 low Map here

      Source: NOAA records through ACIS, winters 1995-96 through 2025-26. What the "carried forward," "gaps filled" and AWOS rows mean is explained in how our microclimate maps work.

      Take your spot to the calculator. Click your ground on the map and open the cold hardiness calculator right there. It'll show you every plant we grow that's come through that cold.

      Open the cold hardiness calculator
      Terrain: USGS 3D Elevation Program. Land cover: NLCD (MRLC). Station records: NOAA via ACIS. Roads and place names: OpenStreetMap contributors. Model and write-up: Montana Fruit Trees, Missoula, Montana.

      Not sure what to plant? We'll pick your trees.

      Tell us about your place, your goals and your budget. We'll pick what fits, build the order for you and email it over within 1 to 2 days.

      Pick my treesIt's free