Microclimate map · Munising, Chatham, Shingleton, Au Train, Trenary, Christmas, Wetmore, Rock River, Eben Junction, Melstrand

Fruit Trees for Munising, Chatham, Shingleton, Au Train and Trenary, Michigan

On February 20, 2015, the Doe Lake Michigan station read −37°F and the Munsing Lakeshore station, 11 miles north-northeast by the bay in Munising, read −21°F. Downtown Munising plans for −23°F, and this map shows where your own ground falls.

On February 20, 2015, the Doe Lake Michigan station, out in the lake country 11 miles south-southwest of Munising, read −37°F. That morning the Munsing Lakeshore station, by the bay in town, read −21°F. On February 28, 2014, the same two read −34°F and −21°F. That gap between the shore and the country behind it is the first thing I'd want you to know about fruit trees for Munising, Chatham, Shingleton, Au Train and Trenary.

The second is how fast things change over a short distance. The hills around Munising Bay are the mildest ground on the map, and on a still night at bloom they read 13°F to 14°F warmer than downtown. Creek bottoms a few miles back on the plateau read 10°F to 13°F colder.

The map runs along Lake Superior from Deerton and Onota past Rock River, Au Train and Christmas to Munising and the Pictured Rocks shore, and it takes in Grand Island. Inland it covers the plateau east to Shingleton, Pines and Cusino, west to Chatham and Rumely, and south to Trenary, Kentucky and Steuben. The east end of Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore, out by Au Sable Light and Grand Marais, is off the map. Type your address in the box on the map and you'll get the number for your own place and the list of what we sell that has come through it.

How to read this map

Every number on the map is a 30-year planning low, the same number our cold hardiness calculator gives, built from NOAA station records since the 1995-96 winter and nudged for the lay of the land. It's the bad night that comes around about once in 30 years. It isn't the record. It's the number I'd plan a tree around. Click a spot and you also get the MFTC zone (that number in half zones), the typical winter (an ordinary year's coldest night, the kind of average USDA's zones are built on) and the spring reading, which is how much warmer or colder that spot runs than downtown Munising on a still, clear night at bloom.

Downtown Munising, on the shore at 607 feet, plans for −23°F, MFTC zone 4b, with a typical winter of −12°F, and it's the zero on the spring layer. The middle of the growing ground plans for −30°F (MFTC zone 4a). Half of it falls between −33°F and −28°F and nine tenths between −37°F and −25°F.

  • Headland 1.8 miles north-northwest of downtown: −18°F (MFTC zone 5a)
  • Hillside 1.1 miles west-northwest: −18°F
  • Kentucky, the coldest named place: −36°F
  • Plain west of Kentucky around the Doe Lake Michigan station: −42°F to −43°F (MFTC zone 2b)

So the hills around Munising Bay are the mild end and that plain is the cold end. Counting the high ground, the map runs from −43°F to −17°F, on ground from 602 feet to 1,104 feet.

The spring layer spreads just as wide. Named places run from Onota, 3.5°F warmer than downtown on a bloom night, to Slapneck, 9.3°F colder. The ground in between runs from 14.5°F warmer on the slopes over the lake to 13°F colder in the creek bottoms on the plateau. I'd pick the tree by the winter number and then pick its spot by the spring one.

Why the map looks the way it does

Water first. Alger County is 82 percent water by area, nearly all of it Lake Superior. Munising sits at about 600 feet at the head of Munising Bay, around the mouth of the Anna River, with Grand Island across the bay. Behind town the ground climbs fast, to 945 to 990 feet on the hillsides a mile east and west of downtown, and northeast of town the shore turns into the Pictured Rocks cliffs. Back from the lake is a plateau, much of it Hiawatha National Forest, with most of the inland towns between 790 and 1,060 feet. South of it, around the Doe Lake Michigan station, is lower country dotted with small lakes.

Big open water holds its heat into the winter and keeps the shore milder. Here's what each station averages for a winter's coldest night:

  • Munsing Lakeshore, at 612 feet by the bay: −11°F
  • Chatham Experiment Farm 2, at 870 feet and 14 miles west-southwest: −20°F
  • Doe Lake Michigan: −22°F

So the planning low falls off fast once you leave the bay:

  • Downtown: −23°F
  • Wetmore: −25°F
  • Indian Town, Juniper and Shingleton, out on the plateau: −26°F to −28°F
  • Chatham: −35°F

Then the lay of the land. On a clear, calm night the ground gives off its heat, the air against it chills, and that cold air runs downhill into the low spots. On the plateau the creek and river bottoms catch it. The bottom half a mile west of Doty reads 12.5°F colder than downtown on a bloom night, and the low ground at the northwest edge of Chatham 12°F colder. Slopes shed the cold. And a slope facing the lake gets the water's help too, so the hills over the bay and above the Pictured Rocks shore read 12°F to 14°F warmer than downtown at bloom. The high ground on Grand Island reads 14.5°F warmer, the best spring reading on the map.

That all holds best on still nights. A deep arctic outbreak can push right past the lake. The Munising station read −33°F on February 25, 1928, and −31°F on February 20, 1929, when the Dukes station, just off the map at 1,100 feet, read −40°F. I'd get the hardiness right first. A good site only adds a margin.

Munising, Christmas, Wetmore and Grand Island

Munising, the Alger County seat, was settled in 1855, and its name is said to come from the Ojibwe minisiing, "at the island." Downtown, on the shore at 607 feet, plans for −23°F, MFTC zone 4b, with a typical winter of −12°F. The town's two stations, a little over half a mile apart, back that up.

  • Munsing Lakeshore, by the bay at 612 feet: coldest −21°F (2013-14) in 20 winters, 1-in-30 number −23°F, the same as the map gives downtown
  • Munising, 70 feet up the slope west of downtown: coldest −19°F (1995-96) in 30 winters, 1-in-30 number −20°F, which matches the map there

The lower one runs colder.

The best fruit ground in Munising is the hills that hold the town.

  • Hillside 1.1 miles west-northwest of downtown, 390 feet above its floor: −18°F, MFTC zone 5a, typical winter −7°F, 14°F warmer than downtown at bloom
  • Slopes 0.8 mile southeast and 1.2 miles east-southeast: −21°F, 13°F to 13.5°F warmer
  • Headland on the west side of the bay, 1.8 miles north-northwest: −18°F, 13°F warmer

On a frost night in May that's 13°F to 14°F of help over downtown. I'd put the stone fruit up the hill.

Christmas, 3.1 miles northwest on the shore, plans for −23°F and reads 0.5°F warmer than downtown at bloom. Williams Landing, 3.2 miles north-northwest across the bay, plans for −21°F and reads 0.3°F colder. Wetmore, 2.5 miles south-southeast on a bench at 879 feet, plans for −25°F (MFTC zone 4b) and reads 0.9°F warmer. The river bottom just southeast of it reads 11°F colder than downtown. And the bench 0.9 mile south, 180 feet above its floor, plans for −22°F and reads 7°F warmer. Munising Junction, 3.7 miles southwest in a creek draw, plans for −26°F (MFTC zone 4a) and reads 3.2°F colder, and the valley floor on the way out there, 2.7 miles from downtown, reads 9°F colder.

Grand Island, the Grand Island National Recreation Area, shows what height and open water do together. Its ground plans for −20°F to −27°F, most of it around −23°F. The high ground on its west side, about 330 feet above the lake, reads 14.5°F warmer than downtown at bloom. By the North Light the hillside plans for −26°F and reads 12°F warmer.

The Pictured Rocks shore, Melstrand, Van Meer and Cusino

Northeast of town the shore becomes the Pictured Rocks, sandstone cliffs up to 200 feet above the lake, colored by iron and copper minerals in the groundwater. Freezing and thawing bring most of the rockfalls, in spring and fall, and Miners Castle lost its inner turret on April 13, 2006. The ground above that shore is lake ground.

  • Slope 3.9 miles northeast of downtown, 270 feet above its floor: −21°F, 14°F warmer than downtown at bloom
  • 6.1 miles out: −23°F
  • 13.9 miles out, 390 feet up: −25°F, still 13.5°F warmer

Several miles back from the water it's flat plateau at 880 to 930 feet, 3°F to 5°F colder than downtown in winter and 4°F to 5°F colder at bloom. Melstrand, at 928 feet, plans for −27°F, MFTC zone 4a, with a typical winter of −14°F, and reads 4.3°F colder. Van Meer plans for −27°F, Myren and Williams Crossing −28°F, and Cusino and Indian Town −26°F.

I'd look for the low hills. The hillside 2 miles north of Melstrand, 120 feet up, plans for −27°F like the town but reads 7°F warmer than downtown, 12°F better than Melstrand itself. The one 1.1 miles northwest of Cusino plans for −26°F and reads 6°F warmer. The river bottom 0.7 mile south of Melstrand reads 9°F colder.

Shingleton, Juniper, Evelyn and Star

Shingleton, named for a shingle mill in 1887, sits on the flat at 827 feet. It plans for −28°F, MFTC zone 4a, with a typical winter of −14°F, and reads 5.1°F colder than downtown Munising on a bloom night. The hillside 1.7 miles north-northwest, 90 feet up, plans for −26°F and reads 5°F warmer than downtown. That's 10°F better than town. The river bottom 1.5 miles northwest reads 10°F colder.

West toward Munising, Juniper, Evelyn and Doty plan for −26°F and read 3°F to 4°F colder. The bottoms between them are some of the worst bloom ground on the map, 11°F colder than downtown 1.2 miles north-northeast of Juniper and 12.5°F colder half a mile west of Doty. The slope 1.4 miles west-northwest of Juniper, 180 feet up at 1,016 feet, plans for −22°F and reads 9°F warmer.

East of Shingleton, Star plans for −27°F and Pines and Creighton −28°F, and they read 4.9°F to 6.4°F colder. It's low, flat country with wetlands, so I'd look for a toe slope. 0.8 mile northeast of Star, 50 feet up, the map gives −26°F and 0.4°F warmer than downtown.

Au Train, Rock River, Onota and Deerton

West of Christmas the shore runs on toward Marquette, and the planning low drops off. Au Train, on the lake by the Au Train River at 607 feet, plans for −30°F, MFTC zone 3b, with a typical winter of −17°F. That's 7°F colder than downtown Munising. It reads 1.8°F colder at bloom. The river bottom 1.2 miles south reads 8°F colder. The bench 2.9 miles east, 220 feet up, plans for −25°F and reads 5.6°F warmer than downtown, and the steep bluff over the lake 2 miles west plans for −30°F but reads 12°F warmer.

Rock River, near the shore at 613 feet, plans for −28°F (MFTC zone 4a) and reads 1.4°F colder, and the slope over the lake 2.4 miles northwest plans for −27°F and reads 9.5°F warmer. Onota, on a hillside at 777 feet, plans for −29°F and reads 3.5°F warmer than downtown, the best bloom reading of any named place. Deerton, on the valley floor at 728 feet, plans for −31°F (MFTC zone 3b) and reads 2.1°F colder. The hillside 2.8 miles east of it, 340 feet up, plans for −28°F and reads 12°F warmer. On this stretch I'd take a slope over the water over a lot down on the flat. Past Deerton and the Sand River, our Marquette, Ishpeming and Negaunee map picks up.

Chatham, Eben Junction, Rumely and Coalwood

Chatham's first settler came in 1896 with the Munising Railway, and Michigan State University's Upper Peninsula Research and Extension Center is there now. The village sits on a toe slope at 871 feet, 14 miles west-southwest of Munising, and plans for −35°F, MFTC zone 3a, with a typical winter of −21°F, 12°F colder than downtown Munising. It reads 0.9°F colder at bloom. That number is well measured.

  • Chatham Experiment Farm 2, half a mile south-southeast: 31 winters on file, coldest −34°F (2002-03), 1-in-30 number −35°F
  • Chatham 1 SE, a mile south-southeast: 22 winters, coldest −32°F (2013-14), 1-in-30 number −34°F

The map gives −35°F at both.

Around the village the bloom night swings hard. The low ground at the northwest edge of Chatham plans for −36°F and reads 12°F colder than downtown Munising. The hillside 1.9 miles northeast, 170 feet up, plans for −33°F and reads 9°F warmer.

  • Eben Junction, 2 miles west-northwest at 964 feet: −34°F, 1.6°F colder at bloom
  • Rumely, at 1,055 feet: −32°F
  • Sundell and Dorsey on the west edge: −33°F
  • Slapneck, on the valley floor 2 miles east of Chatham: −35°F, 9.3°F colder, the worst bloom reading of any named place

Toward Munising it gets milder. Coalwood, on a bench at 1,005 feet, plans for −30°F (MFTC zone 4a) and reads 1.7°F warmer, and the hillside 3 miles northeast of it, 250 feet up, plans for −23°F and reads 11°F warmer.

Trenary, Traunik, Limestone and Kentucky

Trenary, about 3 miles inside the south edge, is the home of Trenary Toast, a Finnish style rusk, and of the Trenary Outhouse Classic, held the last Saturday of February since 1993. It sits in a river bottom at 871 feet and plans for −35°F, MFTC zone 3a, with a typical winter of −20°F, and reads 6.1°F colder than downtown Munising at bloom. The bottom right at the edge of town reads 12°F colder. Traunik, by the Mikulich General Store, plans for −34°F, and Limestone, Kiva, Ladoga and Diffin −33°F. The river bottom 1.9 miles south-southwest of Limestone reads 11°F colder, and the slope 2.8 miles northeast of it, 120 feet up, 8°F warmer.

Kentucky, on a toe slope at 860 feet, plans for −36°F, MFTC zone 3a, the coldest of any named place, and reads 1.6°F colder at bloom. West of it is the coldest ground on the map.

  • Doe Lake Michigan station, 4.1 miles west-southwest: −42°F on the map (MFTC zone 2b)
  • River bottom 1.7 miles west-southwest of Kentucky: −42°F, 12°F colder at bloom
  • Low ground 2.7 miles west: −43°F

Even here the hillside 0.8 mile southwest of Kentucky, 160 feet up, plans for −37°F and reads 9°F warmer. Steuben, near the south edge at 736 feet, plans for −33°F, and the hillside 2.2 miles north-northwest of it −29°F and 4°F warmer.

The plain's numbers lean on one young record. The Doe Lake Michigan station's average winter low, −22°F, is only 2°F colder than the Chatham Experiment Farm 2 station's, but its 1-in-30 number is −44°F against Chatham's −35°F, so its bad winters run a lot further from its average. The −42°F the map gives there is 5°F past the station's worst night in 21 winters, −37°F on February 20, 2015. We'd plan on it, and know it rests on one station.

Spring frost and bloom around Munising

The Munising station's median last 32°F frost, 1991 to 2020, is May 16, and its median first in fall is October 15. That's a frost free season of 151 days. The station sits 0.7 mile west of downtown at 680 feet, on the slope above the bay.

A mid-May median puts the early bloomers in flower while frost is still likely, and MSU Extension's backyard tree fruit tip sheet warns that apricots and peaches flower early and spring frosts often cost the crop. On a still bloom night the hills over the bay, the ground above the Pictured Rocks and Grand Island read 12°F to 14.5°F warmer than downtown. The plateau towns read 3°F to 6°F colder. And the bottoms around Juniper, Doty, Chatham, Trenary and Kentucky read 10°F to 13°F colder.

So I'd let the spring layer place your trees. Apricots go highest, on a slope over the bay or the lake, then plums, cherries and peaches. Keep pears off the low ground too, since they bloom early. Apples, applecrabs and bush fruit can take the flats. And look downhill before you plant. A hedge, a woodlot edge or a road grade across the slope below your trees backs the cold air up into them, so leave a gap at the low end.

What the weather records say

The coldest reading in the long records around this map is −44°F, at the Chatham Experiment Farm station on February 1, 1918. Four days later the Munising station read −28°F. Other big ones:

  • February 9, 1934: Dukes, just off the map, −42°F and Chatham Experiment Farm −39°F
  • February 18, 1979: Chatham Experiment Farm −36°F, the day after Munising hit −27°F

Munising's own record, in 102 years, is −33°F on February 25, 1928.

Since the 1995-96 winter it's been milder. Here are the coldest readings since then:

  • Doe Lake Michigan: −37°F (February 20, 2015)
  • Chatham Experiment Farm 2: −34°F (March 3, 2003)
  • Chatham 1 SE: −32°F (February 28, 2014)
  • Munsing Lakeshore: −21°F (February 28, 2014, and again February 20, 2015)
  • Munising: −19°F (1995-96)

Over its 102 years the Munising station averaged −16°F for the year's coldest night. Since 1995-96 its average winter low is −10°F.

The planning low isn't the worst night. Downtown's −23°F is 2°F past anything the Munsing Lakeshore station has seen in its 20 winters, but the Munising station's 1928 record is 10°F past it, and Chatham Experiment Farm's −44°F in 1918 is 9°F past what Chatham plans for now. If you want a tree to ride out a 1918 or 1928 kind of winter, go a step hardier than your band.

USDA's 2023 map puts Munising's 49862 ZIP code in zone 5b (−15°F to −10°F), and the Chatham (49816) and Shingleton (49884) ZIP codes in zone 5a (−20°F to −15°F). USDA's zones are built on the average of each winter's coldest night, about our typical winter, which is −12°F downtown, −14°F at Shingleton and −21°F at Chatham. Ours is built on the bad night you plan for:

  • MFTC zone 5a: the hills over the bay
  • 4b: downtown
  • 4a: the plateau around Shingleton
  • 3a: Chatham and Trenary
  • 2b: around the Doe Lake Michigan station

Then there's the snow. The Munising station's normal snowfall, 1991 to 2020, is 161 inches a year, 46 inches of it in January, and the Chatham 1 SE station's is 164 inches. Lake effect snow gives the Munising area some of the heaviest snowfall in the country.

What you can grow here

Start with the winter number. Anything we sell rated −45°F or colder has come through colder than every planning low on this map, and anything rated −40°F or colder clears at least 95 percent of the growing ground. I'd pick by your band, then by the spring layer.

The hills over Munising Bay, downtown and the Pictured Rocks shore, −18°F to −25°F

Downtown Munising, Christmas, Williams Landing, Wetmore and the slopes around the bay and above the Pictured Rocks shore.

Shingleton, Melstrand, Au Train and the plateau, −26°F to −30°F

Indian Town, Juniper, Evelyn, Doty, Cusino, Munising Junction, Star, Melstrand, Van Meer, Myren, Williams Crossing, Pines, Shingleton, Creighton, Rock River, Onota, Coalwood and Au Train. The −30°F trees fit all of it, right at the line at Coalwood and Au Train. Here's what I'd plant.

Chatham, Trenary, Eben Junction and the cold side, −31°F to −36°F

Deerton, Stillman, Vail, Rumely, Kiva, Diffin, Steuben, Sundell, Ladoga, Dorsey, Limestone, Eben Junction, Traunik, Slapneck, Trenary, Chatham, Dixon and Kentucky. Everything rated −40°F or colder has come through colder than this. The −35°F trees are right at the line at Chatham, Trenary, Slapneck and Dixon and don't fit Kentucky (−36°F). Siberian C is the only peach for this side, on your best ground.

The Doe Lake country and the coldest bottoms, −37°F to −43°F

The plain west of Kentucky around the Doe Lake Michigan station, and the worst bottoms east of Chatham and Limestone. I'd stick to varieties rated −45°F or colder. At −43°F that leaves 2°F to spare, and the −50°F ones a lot more.

Matching trees to the spring layer

Where your spot reads warmer than downtown Munising on the spring layer, that's ground for apricots, peaches, plums and cherries. Where it reads 5°F or more colder, I'd plant apples, applecrabs and bush fruit like Honeyberry, Golden Currant and Sea Buckthorn (both −50°F). Most apples, pears and plums need a second variety blooming with them, and our pollination maps show the pairings.

Questions people ask

When is the last frost in Munising?

The Munising station's median last 32°F frost, 1991 to 2020, is May 16, and its median first fall frost is October 15, a frost free season of 151 days. On a still bloom night the hills over the bay run 13°F to 14°F warmer than downtown, so that's where I'd put the early bloomers.

What growing zone is Munising, Michigan?

USDA's 2023 map puts Munising's 49862 ZIP code in zone 5b, −15°F to −10°F, built on an average winter's coldest night. Our map has downtown Munising planning for −23°F, MFTC zone 4b, with a typical winter of −12°F. The hills right over the bay plan for −18°F to −21°F. Chatham, back on the plateau, plans for −35°F (MFTC zone 3a).

Can you grow peaches in Munising?

Yes. Downtown plans for −23°F, and every peach we sell has come through −25°F or colder. Glohaven and Redstar are −25°F, Contender, Blushingstar and Veteran −30°F, and Siberian C −35°F. Bloom is the risk with a May 16 median last frost, so I'd plant them on the hills over the bay that read 13°F to 14°F warmer on a frost night. At Shingleton (−28°F) stick with the −30°F and −35°F peaches, and at Chatham (−35°F) only Siberian C, right at the line.

Where are the frost pockets around Munising?

The creek and river bottoms back on the plateau. On a still bloom night the bottom half a mile west of Doty reads 12.5°F colder than downtown Munising and the low ground at the northwest edge of Chatham 12°F colder. The bottoms near Juniper and just southeast of Wetmore read 11°F colder. In winter the coldest ground is the plain west of Kentucky around the Doe Lake Michigan station, at −42°F to −43°F.

How cold does it get in Munising?

The Munising station's record is −33°F, on February 25, 1928, in 102 years of records, and it read −31°F on February 20, 1929. Since the 1995-96 winter its coldest is −19°F, and the Munsing Lakeshore station's is −21°F. Our map plans for −23°F downtown. That's the 1-in-30 night, not the record.

Why is Chatham so much colder than Munising?

Chatham sits up on the plateau at 871 feet, back from the lake that keeps Munising's shore milder. The Chatham Experiment Farm 2 station's average winter low is −20°F against −11°F at the Munsing Lakeshore station, and its 1-in-30 number is −35°F against −23°F. Our map has Chatham at −35°F and downtown Munising at −23°F.

Warmer spots, colder spots

Here's what to plan for at named places on the map, warmest first. Each one is the 1-in-30-year low for that spot. It's the cold hardiness calculator's number off the same weather stations, and then our microclimate model sharpens it for the ground right there. Zone means our MFTC zone, and that comes from the one bad night, not an average.

Runs warmer

    Runs colder

      How this map works

      Every number on this map is a 30-year planning low, same as our cold hardiness calculator gives you. I build it from NOAA station records and lean it a little cold on purpose, then nudge it a degree or two for the ground right around you. The spring frost layer runs our whole terrain model, which follows cold air down the draws and into the bottoms. Plan with it but don't treat it like a promise. How long the cold hangs on matters, so do wind and soil and those warm spells in late winter.

      If you want the physics of cold air, how I build the number, every terrain weight and where the model falls short, it's all on one page: how our microclimate maps work.

      The weather stations behind it

      These are the long record stations in and around this map, with each one's own numbers since the winter of 1995-96. The last column is the map's 30-year number right at the station. It won't match the station exactly, because it's a blend of the stations around it. That's how the calculator does it everywhere.

      Station Elev (ft) Winters Coldest since 1995 Average winter low 1-in-30 low Map here

      Source: NOAA records through ACIS, winters 1995-96 through 2025-26. What the "carried forward," "gaps filled" and AWOS rows mean is explained in how our microclimate maps work.

      Take your spot to the calculator. Click your ground on the map and open the cold hardiness calculator right there. It'll show you every plant we grow that's come through that cold.

      Open the cold hardiness calculator
      Terrain: USGS 3D Elevation Program. Land cover: NLCD (MRLC). Station records: NOAA via ACIS. Roads and place names: OpenStreetMap contributors. Model and write-up: Montana Fruit Trees, Missoula, Montana.

      Not sure what to plant? We'll pick your trees.

      Tell us about your place, your goals and your budget. We'll pick what fits, build the order for you and email it over within 1 to 2 days.

      Pick my treesIt's free