On January 19, 1994, the Slippery Rock 1 SSW station read −28°F, the coldest reading on any station record inside this map. The Butler 2 SW station, 1.6 miles from downtown Butler, bottomed out at −20°F the next morning, and the Butler Eagle reported highs of −1°F and −2°F at Butler's NOAA station those two days. That 8°F gap is the first thing I'd tell you about fruit trees for Butler, Slippery Rock, Zelienople, Harmony and Saxonburg. The north end of the county runs colder than the south. The second thing is the creeks. On a still night at bloom the worst draws run 13°F or more colder than downtown Butler, and the best hillsides 9°F to 11°F warmer.
The map covers most of Butler County. It starts with Zelienople, Harmony and Evans City in the southwest and Saxonburg and Cabot in the southeast, runs past Butler and Moraine State Park, and goes up to Slippery Rock, Harrisville and Boyers in the north and Chicora, Karns City and Petrolia in the northeast. It takes in the Allegheny too, from Foxburg down past Parker to East Brady. Put your address in the box on the map and you'll get the number at your own place and the list of what we sell that has come through it.
How to read this map
Every number on the map is a 30-year planning low, the same number our cold hardiness calculator gives, nudged for the lay of the land. It's the night that comes around about once in 30 years. It isn't the record. Click a spot and you also get the MFTC zone, which is that number in half zones, and the typical winter, an ordinary year's coldest night, the kind of average USDA's zones are built on. And you get the spring reading, how much warmer or colder the spot runs than downtown Butler on a still, clear night at bloom.
Downtown Butler, by the courthouse at 1,065 feet, plans for −18°F (MFTC zone 5a) with a typical winter of −3°F. The middle of the growing ground plans for −19°F. Half of it falls between −20°F and −17°F, and nine tenths between −23°F and −15°F. The ends look like this:
- Steep hillsides around Harmony and Zelienople: −13°F
- Connoquenessing, Meadowood and Saxonburg: −15°F (MFTC zone 5b)
- Plain Grove and Bovard: −24°F
- Crolls Mills: −25°F, just into MFTC zone 4a
So the south is the mild end and the Slippery Rock Creek country in the northwest is the cold end. All told the map runs from −26°F to −12°F, on ground from 818 feet to 1,582 feet.
The spring layer spreads wider. Among named places it goes from 13°F colder than downtown Butler on a still bloom night to 9°F warmer. I'd use winter to tell you what will live here. Spring tells you where on your place to put it.
Why the map looks the way it does
The glaciers drew a line across this map. At least four continental glaciers reached their greatest extent just north of Moraine State Park and dammed Slippery Rock Creek, McConnells Run and Muddy Creek into lakes. When one of them, Lake Prouty, spilled south, it started cutting the Slippery Rock Gorge, which runs 400 feet deep. The ice left rolling hills topped with hardwoods and swamps in the valley bottoms. And those wide, flat floors are where this map runs coldest. Harrisville, on flat ground at 1,312 feet, plans for −23°F, and the valley floor 1.9 miles west-southwest of Slippery Rock plans for −26°F, as cold as this map gets.
South of the park the land drains to Connoquenessing Creek, which runs southwest through Butler, then west-northwest past Harmony and Zelienople. The hills there stand as much as 400 feet above their floors, and they're the mild side of the map. The station records lean the same way. Since the 1995-96 winter:
- Slippery Rock 1 SSW: average winter low −6°F, 1-in-30 number −22°F
- Butler 2 SW: −4°F and −19°F
Inside that split, the creeks do the rest. On a clear, calm night the ground gives up its heat, the air on it chills, and that cold air slides downhill and pools in the bottoms while the slopes above sit in the thermal belt the cold drains past. Harmony Junction, in a draw at 904 feet, plans for −19°F and reads 13°F colder than downtown Butler on a still bloom night. The hillside 0.8 mile south-southeast of Harmony sits 310 feet above its floor and about a mile from the draw. It plans for −14°F and reads 9°F warmer. That's 22°F apart on the same night.
Town heat adds about 2.5°F downtown. And all of this holds best on still nights. A deep arctic outbreak like January 1994, when NWS Pittsburgh's records show 52 straight hours at or below 0°F, fills hilltop and bottom alike. So I'd make sure the variety is hardy enough first.
Downtown Butler, Lyndora, Meridian and East Butler
Butler, the county seat, sits along Connoquenessing Creek, the only waterway through the city. Downtown plans for −18°F, MFTC zone 5a, with a typical winter of −3°F, and it's what the spring layer measures against. Within 3 miles the planning low runs from −20°F on the valley floor 2.4 miles north-northeast, toward Oneida, to −14°F (zone 5b) on the hillside 1.1 miles south-southeast. That hillside sits 270 feet above its floor and reads 7°F warmer at bloom too.
The neighborhoods by the creek run cold in spring. Climb the hill and it flips. Here's the bloom night against downtown:
- The Island, a quarter mile from the courthouse: −19°F, 7°F colder
- South Side: 8°F colder
- Vogleyville, in a draw 1.9 miles east-southeast: 11°F colder
- North Butler and East Butler, on toe slopes: −19°F, 1°F to 2°F colder
- West End: −18°F, 5°F warmer
- South Hills: −16°F, 4°F warmer
- Lyndora: −17°F, 5°F warmer
- Meadowood, on the bench 280 feet up a mile south of downtown: −15°F (zone 5b), 6°F warmer
Meridian, on a bench 3.5 miles west, plans for −15°F. I'd put the apricots, peaches and sweet cherries on the south hills and keep the creek neighborhoods for apples and bush fruit.
Zelienople, Harmony, Evans City and Connoquenessing
Zelienople and Harmony sit side by side on the Connoquenessing, Harmony 0.8 mile to the northeast. Zelienople, home of the Passavant House, sits on the valley floor at 951 feet and plans for −17°F, MFTC zone 5a, with a typical winter of −2°F. It reads 5°F colder than downtown Butler at bloom. Harmony is on the creek bottom at 927 feet and plans for −19°F, typical winter −4°F, and reads 5.5°F colder. Harmony Junction, in a draw 1.3 miles east-southeast, reads 13.4°F colder. That's the coldest spring reading of any named place on the map.
But the hills right above them are some of the mildest ground on the map. The hillside a mile southeast of Harmony, 350 feet above its floor, plans for −13°F (MFTC zone 5b) with a typical winter of 2°F and reads 9°F warmer. The slopes 1.4 miles west of Zelienople plan for −13°F and read 9°F warmer too. Middle Lancaster, on a hillside 250 feet up north of Harmony along Route 19, plans for −16°F and reads 5°F warmer.
Evans City is 4 miles east-southeast of Harmony on a toe slope at 990 feet. It plans for −16°F, typical winter −2°F, and reads 1°F colder than downtown Butler at bloom. The hillside a mile south-southwest, 230 feet up, plans for −13°F and reads 8°F warmer, and Buhls Station, in a draw 2.7 miles northeast, reads nearly 13°F colder. Connoquenessing, on a bench 310 feet above its floor, plans for −15°F (zone 5b) with a typical winter of 0°F and reads 5°F warmer. South toward Cranberry Township, our Pittsburgh and the Three Rivers map picks up.
Saxonburg, Cabot, Herman and Worthington
Saxonburg, home of the John Roebling House, sits right on the south edge of the map on a bench 150 feet above its floor at 1,304 feet. It plans for −15°F, MFTC zone 5b, with a typical winter of 0°F, and reads 1°F warmer than downtown Butler at bloom. Hannahstown, on the bench 1.8 miles northeast, plans for −15°F and reads 4°F warmer. The draws between the benches run cold, though:
- Cabot, 2.7 miles east-northeast on a steep toe slope: −17°F, 6.5°F colder
- Jefferson Center, 2 miles north-northwest of Saxonburg: nearly 13°F colder
- Herman, on a hillside toward Butler: −16°F, 2.5°F colder
East toward the Allegheny it runs colder. Worthington, on a hillside, plans for −19°F and reads about even with downtown Butler. But Buffalo Mills, in the draw 0.6 mile west, plans for −20°F and reads 10°F colder, and Craigsville plans for −21°F and reads 11°F colder. Southeast toward Freeport, our Johnstown, Greensburg and the Laurel Highlands map covers you.
Prospect, Portersville, Muddy Creek and Moraine State Park
Northwest of Butler, Moraine State Park wraps around Lake Arthur, 3,225 acres behind the Muddy Creek dam, finished in 1968. Prospect is on a bench 160 feet above its floor at 1,351 feet. It plans for −18°F, MFTC zone 5a, with a typical winter of −3°F, and reads 2°F colder than downtown Butler at bloom. Portersville, on a hillside 190 feet up 5.3 miles west-northwest, plans for −17°F and reads 4°F warmer. Portersville Hill, just northeast of it, plans for −17°F and reads 8°F warmer.
Farther north the floors run colder. Muddy Creek, the village, sits at the foot of its slope, plans for −21°F (zone 4b) and reads 7°F colder. West Liberty plans for −22°F and reads 6°F colder. On the west edge, Slippery Rock Creek runs through its gorge in McConnells Mill State Park. Out that way Kennedy Mill, in a draw, plans for −22°F and reads 12°F colder, and Princeton, on a bench 210 feet up, plans for −17°F and reads 3°F warmer.
Slippery Rock, Harrisville, Boyers and Slippery Rock Creek
Slippery Rock, home of Slippery Rock University, was incorporated as Centreville in 1841 and renamed in 1896. The borough sits in a draw at 1,284 feet and plans for −21°F, MFTC zone 4b, with a typical winter of −6°F. It reads 5°F colder than downtown Butler at bloom. The Slippery Rock 1 SSW station, 0.7 mile south, has a 1-in-30 number of −22°F, and the map plans for −21°F there.
This is the coldest corner of the map. Within 3 miles the planning low runs from −26°F on the flat valley floor 1.9 miles west-southwest (MFTC zone 4a, typical winter −10°F) to −20°F on the hillside 0.8 mile northeast, 210 feet up, which reads 5°F warmer than downtown Butler at bloom. Slippery Rock Creek runs in its valley 2 miles south of town, and the ground along it plans for −23°F to −25°F:
- Rock Falls Park: −24°F
- Crolls Mills: −25°F (zone 4a)
- Slippery Rock Park, in its draw: −23°F, 11°F colder at bloom
Upstream, the creek heads near Hilliards and runs west past Boyers and Branchton. Boyers, on the creek bottom at 1,202 feet, plans for −23°F with a typical winter of −8°F and reads 10°F colder at bloom. Bovard, in a draw near Branchton, plans for −24°F and reads 12°F colder. Up here the benches are the fruit ground. Boyers Hill, 1.4 miles south-southeast of Boyers and 310 feet above its floor, plans for −19°F and reads 7°F warmer.
Harrisville, north-northeast of Slippery Rock, sits on flat ground at 1,312 feet and plans for −23°F, typical winter −8°F, and the bottoms within 2 miles of it −25°F. Plain Grove, west of Slippery Rock, plans for −24°F and McCoys Corners −25°F. In this corner I'd stick with the hardiest trees and put every stone fruit on a bench or a hillside. West over the Ohio line, our Canton, Youngstown and Warren map covers you.
Chicora, Karns City, West Sunbury and Eau Claire
Northeast of Butler the ground climbs toward 1,500 feet. Chicora, on an 18 percent hillside at 1,292 feet, plans for −20°F (MFTC zone 4b) with a typical winter of −5°F and reads 4°F warmer than downtown Butler at bloom. Karns City, 3.2 miles north-northeast of Chicora, plans for −22°F, typical winter −7°F. The rest, against downtown at bloom:
- Millerstown, in the draw half a mile northwest of Chicora: −22°F, 9°F colder
- Saint Joe, on a bench 230 feet up 3.6 miles south-southwest: −15°F, 7°F warmer
- Karns City: 7°F colder
- Petrolia, in its draw: −20°F, 11°F colder
- Fairview, on a bench 180 feet up 1.3 miles west of Petrolia: −18°F, 4°F warmer
West Sunbury, on a bench at 1,386 feet, plans for −19°F and reads 1°F warmer. Up near the north edge, Eau Claire sits on a bench at 1,520 feet and plans for −19°F, reading 4°F warmer. And Annisville Hill, 3.4 miles south of it at 1,575 feet, near the top of the map, plans for −18°F and reads 9°F warmer.
Parker, East Brady, Foxburg and the Allegheny
The Allegheny runs down the east edge of the map, its bottom at about 850 feet at Parker and the hills above it past 1,400 feet. Parker was incorporated in 1873 during the oil boom and is sometimes called the Smallest City in the USA. It sits above the river at 1,022 feet and plans for −21°F, MFTC zone 4b, with a typical winter of −6°F, and reads 1.6°F warmer than downtown Butler at bloom. The river bottom just east of town plans for −22°F and reads 12°F colder. The hillside 2.2 miles north, 430 feet above its floor, plans for −17°F and reads 10°F warmer, one of the best spring readings on the map.
Upriver, Foxburg, on a 25 percent slope at 955 feet, plans for −20°F and reads 3°F colder. Downriver, Bradys Bend, at the foot of its slope, plans for −21°F and reads 9.5°F colder, and East Brady, on a hillside 100 feet above its floor, plans for −20°F and reads 1°F warmer. The old East Brady station, at 850 feet, read −27°F on January 29, 1963. Its yearly low averaged −11°F over 28 years between 1919 and 1974, the coldest average of any long record inside the map. Dutch Hill, on a hillside 410 feet up 3.2 miles southeast of Parker, plans for −17°F and reads 9°F warmer. Along the river I'd put the apricots and peaches up on ground like that.
Spring frost and bloom around Butler
The Butler 2 SW station's median last 32°F frost, 1991 to 2020, is May 7, and its median first fall frost is October 13, a frost free season of 160 days. That thermometer sits 1.6 miles southwest of downtown at 1,000 feet, near the valley floor, where our spring layer reads about 7°F colder than downtown on a still bloom night. So on the hills above town I think May 7 is on the safe side.
Spring 2026 showed what a bloom freeze costs. That April was Pittsburgh's warmest on record. But a hard freeze on April 8 brought lows in the low 20s°F, and another on April 21 hit at full bloom, and during that spell the Butler County Airport station dropped to 25°F. Penn State's Dan Weber estimated the losses:
- Plums and cherries: nearly all
- Peaches: 70 to 90 percent
- Apples: 80 to 95 percent
At full bloom, 25°F is about where Penn State says 90 percent of apple and sweet cherry blossoms die.
So site is the frost protection that counts here, and Penn State calls good site selection the most economical and effective one there is. I'd give apricots the highest slope you have, then peaches, plums and sweet cherries, and keep pears off the low ground. Apples bloom later and can go lower, with currants, gooseberries and honeyberries. And look downhill. A hedgerow, fence or road fill across the slope below your trees backs the cold up into them, so leave a gap at the low end.
What the weather records say
The coldest reading in the long station records around this map is −32°F, at Grove City, just north of it, on January 13, 1912. Inside the map the record is the Slippery Rock 1 SSW station's −28°F on January 19, 1994. The East Brady station read −27°F on January 29, 1963.
Butler runs milder. In 42 years from 1968 to 2019 the Butler 2 SW station's coldest was −20°F, and it hit that three times, on January 14, 1977, January 21, 1984 and January 20, 1994. Since the 1995-96 winter the Butler 2 SW station's coldest is −18°F, in 2014-15. The Slippery Rock 1 SSW station's is −24°F, in the 2025-26 winter, 2°F past its 1-in-30 number.
USDA's 2023 map, by ZIP code, puts Butler, Slippery Rock, Cabot, Harrisville and Parker in zone 6a (−10°F to −5°F) and Harmony and Zelienople in 6b (−5°F to 0°F). USDA's zones are built on an average winter's coldest night, close to our typical winter, which in those towns runs from −2°F at Zelienople to −8°F at Harrisville. Ours are built on the bad night we plan for.
- MFTC zone 5b: Saxonburg and Connoquenessing
- 5a: Butler, Zelienople and Harmony
- 4b: Slippery Rock, Parker and Harrisville
- 4a: the coldest floors around Slippery Rock
What you can grow here
Every plant we sell except Chicago Hardy Fig (−10°F) has come through −20°F or colder. Everything rated −30°F or colder has come through colder than any ground on this map, which bottoms out at −26°F. So the sorting here comes down to the −20°F and −25°F trees, and to bloom. The fig doesn't clear even the mildest hillside.
The mild hills, −13°F to −16°F
Saxonburg, Connoquenessing, Meadowood and Saint Joe (−15°F), Evans City, South Hills and Middle Lancaster (−16°F), and the hillsides above Harmony and Zelienople (−13°F to −14°F). Everything but the fig fits here.
- The −20°F trees, with room to spare: Bing cherry, Santa Rosa plum, Mericrest and Arctic Glo nectarines, Baldwin and St. Edmund's Pippin apples, and Javid's Iranian Seedling almond
- The −25°F group, with more room still: Stella cherry, Glowingstar and Risingstar peaches, Red Gold nectarine, Glockenapfel apple, SnowCzar almond, Purvis Hardy English walnut and Persimmon (Montana Trial)
Downtown Butler and the middle ground, −17°F to −20°F
Zelienople, Cabot, Portersville and Lyndora (−17°F), downtown Butler, Prospect and Fairview (−18°F), Harmony, East Butler, West Sunbury and Eau Claire (−19°F), and Chicora, East Brady, Foxburg and Petrolia (−20°F). The −20°F trees have come through all of it. But at −19°F there's only 1°F to spare and at −20°F they're right at the line, so I'd give them your warmest spot. These have room to spare:
- Peaches: Contender, Blushingstar and Veteran (−30°F)
- Apricots: Harlayne and Goldrich (−30°F)
- Sweet cherry: Lapins (−35°F)
- Plums: Stanley and Shiro (−30°F)
- Pears: Seckel (−35°F) and Clapp's Favorite (−30°F)
- Apples: Northern Spy, Roxbury Russet and Stayman Winesap (−30°F) and Liberty (−35°F)
- And Montana Trial Pawpaw (−30°F), Aromatnaya Russian quince (−30°F) and Concord grape (−30°F)
Slippery Rock, Parker and the cold floors, −21°F to −26°F
Slippery Rock, Parker and Bradys Bend (−21°F), Karns City, Bruin and West Liberty (−22°F), Harrisville and Boyers (−23°F), Plain Grove and Bovard (−24°F), Crolls Mills, Currys Mills and McCoys Corners (−25°F), and the floor west-southwest of Slippery Rock (−26°F). I'd leave out the −20°F trees. The −25°F trees, like Glowingstar and Stella, have come through the −21°F to −24°F ground, are right at the line at −25°F and fall short on the −26°F floor. Everything rated −30°F or colder clears all of it, and with Slippery Rock's −28°F in 1994 in mind I'd lean on the hardiest:
- Peach: Siberian C (−35°F)
- Apricots: Westcot (−45°F) and Sungold (−40°F)
- Cherries: Black Gold sweet cherry (−35°F), Montmorency (−35°F) and Evan's Bali (−45°F) tart cherries
- Plums: Toka (−45°F) and Superior (−35°F)
- Pears: Ure and Summercrisp (−45°F) and Luscious (−40°F)
- Apples: Haralson and Honeycrisp (−45°F), Cortland (−40°F) and Wolf River (−50°F)
- Applecrabs: Chestnut and Kerr (−50°F)
Matching trees to the spring layer
Where your spot reads warmer than downtown Butler at bloom, I'd plant apricots, peaches, sweet cherries and plums. That's the south hills, the benches around Saxonburg and Saint Joe, and the hillsides above Harmony, Zelienople and Parker. Most plums want a partner, and Toka is a good pollenizer for Superior. Apples and pears need a second variety blooming with them too, and our pollination maps show the pairings. Where it reads 5°F or more colder than downtown (The Island, Harmony Junction, Buhls Station, Petrolia, Boyers, Bovard, Bradys Bend), I'd stick with apples, applecrabs and bush fruit:
- Honeyberry (−50°F)
- Pink Champagne currant (−40°F)
- Invicta gooseberry (−40°F)
- Boyne raspberry (−50°F)
Fruit history here
Fruit here goes back at least to the Harmony Society, which settled on the Connoquenessing at Harmony from 1804 to 1814 and cleared land for vineyards and crops. An 1806 petition already said the climate wasn't well suited to grapes. But by 1807 they had a four-acre vineyard, later called Vineyard Hill, and two wine cellars, and by 1810 two apple orchards held about 2,000 trees. Wine grapes like Marquette (−35°F) and La Crescent (−40°F) have come through far colder than anything on this map.
The cider presses are still running. Sally's Cider Press, Tom and Sally Davis's place on Perry Highway in Lancaster Township outside Harmony, used to be Young's Cider Press. It works a 125-year-old Mt. Gilead press, and customers bring their own apples. At Metrick's Harvest View Farm in Connoquenessing Township, Ken and Cathy Metrick press cider on an 1880s Boomer & Boschert press. Rustic Acres Winery in Butler makes apple wines, The Barn at Soergel Hollow has pick-your-own apples and grapes, and Bowser's Blueberries, 6 miles west of Butler, grows 10 varieties for u-pick. Our Cold Climate Blueberry Bundle (−40°F) has come through far colder than this county gets. And in Cherry Township, most agree the name came from all the cherry trees.
Questions people ask
When is the last frost in Butler?
The Butler 2 SW station's median last 32°F frost, 1991 to 2020, is May 7, and its median first fall frost is October 13, a frost free season of 160 days. On a still spring night the hills around Butler run warmer than that station's spot near the valley floor, and the creek bottoms colder, so I'd check yours on the spring layer.
What growing zone is Butler, PA?
USDA's 2023 map puts Butler's 16001 ZIP in zone 6a, built on an average winter. Our map has downtown Butler planning for −18°F, MFTC zone 5a, with a typical winter of −3°F. Meadowood, on the bench south of downtown, plans for −15°F (zone 5b).
What growing zone is Slippery Rock, PA?
USDA's 2023 map puts Slippery Rock's 16057 ZIP in zone 6a. Our map has the borough planning for −21°F, MFTC zone 4b, with a typical winter of −6°F, and the creek bottoms south of town −23°F to −25°F. The Slippery Rock 1 SSW station hit −28°F in 1994, so I'd lean on trees rated −30°F or colder there.
Can you grow peaches in Butler?
Yes. Downtown plans for −18°F, and every peach we sell has come through −25°F or colder. Contender, Blushingstar and Veteran have come through −30°F. Bloom is the bigger risk, so I'd plant them on a hillside that reads warm on the spring layer, like West End or Meadowood (5°F and 6°F warmer than downtown on a still bloom night), not The Island (7°F colder).
Where are the frost pockets around Butler County?
The draws and creek bottoms. On a still bloom night Harmony Junction reads 13.4°F colder than downtown Butler, Buhls Station and Jefferson Center 12.7°F colder, and Kennedy Mill, Bovard and Oneida about 12°F colder. In winter the coldest ground is the flat valley floors around Slippery Rock and along Slippery Rock Creek, −24°F to −26°F.
Why is Slippery Rock colder than Butler?
The station records say it is. Since the 1995-96 winter the Slippery Rock 1 SSW station's average winter low is −6°F against −4°F at Butler 2 SW, and its 1-in-30 number is −22°F against −19°F. It also sits in the glaciated country north of Moraine State Park, where wide, flat floors hold the cold.
Warmer spots, colder spots
Here's what to plan for at named places on the map, warmest first. Each one is the 1-in-30-year low for that spot. It's the cold hardiness calculator's number off the same weather stations, and then our microclimate model sharpens it for the ground right there. Zone means our MFTC zone, and that comes from the one bad night, not an average.
Runs warmer
Runs colder
How this map works
Every number on this map is a 30-year planning low, same as our cold hardiness calculator gives you. I build it from NOAA station records and lean it a little cold on purpose, then nudge it a degree or two for the ground right around you. The spring frost layer runs our whole terrain model, which follows cold air down the draws and into the bottoms. Plan with it but don't treat it like a promise. How long the cold hangs on matters, so do wind and soil and those warm spells in late winter.
If you want the physics of cold air, how I build the number, every terrain weight and where the model falls short, it's all on one page: how our microclimate maps work.
The weather stations behind it
These are the long record stations in and around this map, with each one's own numbers since the winter of 1995-96. The last column is the map's 30-year number right at the station. It won't match the station exactly, because it's a blend of the stations around it. That's how the calculator does it everywhere.
| Station | Elev (ft) | Winters | Coldest since 1995 | Average winter low | 1-in-30 low | Map here |
|---|
Source: NOAA records through ACIS, winters 1995-96 through 2025-26. What the "carried forward," "gaps filled" and AWOS rows mean is explained in how our microclimate maps work.
Take your spot to the calculator. Click your ground on the map and open the cold hardiness calculator right there. It'll show you every plant we grow that's come through that cold.
Open the cold hardiness calculator