On January 19, 1970:
- Mitchell 2 N station, at 1,250 feet: −38°F
- Bridgewater, just east of the map: −35°F
- White Lake, up at 1,629 feet just west of it: −32°F
On February 10, 1994, Mitchell 2 N went to −40°F, its coldest in 99 years. That's where I'd start with fruit trees for Mitchell, Plankinton, Alexandria, Mount Vernon and Ethan. Half the growing ground plans for −32°F to −30°F. But the James and its creeks cut colder ground through it, and town heat keeps Mitchell milder, and on a still night at bloom the bottoms run up to 11.5°F colder than downtown Mitchell while the bluffs right above them run up to 9.5°F warmer.
The map runs from Aurora Center and Plankinton on the west to Emery and Epiphany on the east, and from Cuthbert and Letcher down to Hillside, Dimock and the Elm Spring colonies on the south edge. That takes in Davison County around Mitchell and Mount Vernon, Hanson County around Alexandria, Aurora County around Plankinton and the edges of the counties next door. The James comes in at the north edge, passes about 3 miles east of downtown Mitchell and runs on southeast past Rosedale and Rockport colonies. Type your address in the box on the map and you'll get the number for your own place, and the list of what we sell that has come through it.
How to read this map
Every number on the map is a 30-year planning low, the kind of night that comes around about once in 30 winters. It's our cold hardiness calculator's number, nudged for the lay of the land. Plan a tree around it. It isn't the record. Click a spot and you also get:
- The MFTC zone (that number in half zones)
- The typical winter, an ordinary year's coldest night, the kind of average USDA's zones are built on
- The spring reading, which is how much warmer or colder that spot runs than downtown Mitchell on a still, clear night at bloom
Downtown Mitchell plans for −28°F, MFTC zone 4a, with a typical winter of −17°F, and it's the zero on the spring layer. The middle of the growing ground plans for −31°F (zone 3b). Half of it falls between −32°F and −30°F, and nine tenths of it between −34°F and −29°F.
The mild end is Mitchell's own south and west sides, at −27°F, and then the upland in the southwest, west of Metzgerville and Hillside, at −27°F to −28°F. The cold end:
- Epiphany and Oak Lane Hutterite Colony: −34°F
- The James bottom at the north edge: −35°F to −36°F
- The northeast corner: −36°F (zone 3a)
Counting every corner, the map runs from −37°F to −26°F, on ground from 1,196 feet to 1,882 feet.
The spring layer spreads a lot wider. Every named place reads within about 5°F of downtown Mitchell on a bloom night, from Epiphany, 5.4°F colder, to Old Elm Spring Hutterite Colony, 3.6°F warmer. But the bottoms read up to 11.5°F colder and the bluffs above the James up to 9.5°F warmer. Winter sorts out which trees can live here. The spring reading sorts out which corner of your place they go in.
Why the map looks the way it does
This is rolling prairie with one real valley through it. Davison County slopes east and rises toward its southwest corner, and Aurora County, around Plankinton, is low rolling hills dotted with small lakes and ponds (Crystal, Hanson, Pleasant and Wilmarth among them). The James bottom runs from about 1,220 feet at the north edge to 1,196 feet between Rockport and Old Elm Spring, the low point of the map, and sits about 100 feet below downtown Mitchell. West of the river the land climbs:
- Mount Vernon: 1,408 feet
- Plankinton: 1,525 feet
- Stickney and Aurora Center: past 1,640 feet
- The far northwest corner, toward Wessington Springs: tops out at 1,882 feet
On a clear, calm night the ground loses its heat and the air against it chills, and that cold air slides downhill and pools on the floors. Here that means the James bottom and the creek bottoms. Firesteel Creek, which was dammed to make Lake Mitchell on the north side of the city, Twelve Mile Creek and Enemy Creek. The bluffs do the opposite, since cold air drains on past a slope. On the west bluff of the James 5.1 miles southeast of downtown Mitchell, a hillside 90 feet above its floor plans for −30°F and reads 8.4°F warmer than downtown at bloom. The bottom 0.6 mile away plans for −33°F and reads 10.7°F colder. That's 19°F apart on the same night.
Height alone doesn't buy much on this map. Stickney and Hillside sit more than 300 feet above Mitchell, but on broad flats only 50 to 80 feet above their own floors, and they plan for −29°F, 1°F colder than downtown. In the far northwest corner, slopes 180 to 250 feet above their floors read up to 11°F warmer than downtown Mitchell at bloom. They still plan for −30°F to −31°F.
Two more things shape the winter map. Town heat is worth about 2.5°F in downtown Mitchell on a still night, far more than in any other town here, and that's a big part of why Mitchell is the mild spot. And the longest station records run colder to the north. Average yearly low over their whole records:
- Mitchell 2 N and Alexandria: −23°F
- Howard, off the northeast corner: −24°F
- Forestburg 4 NNE, just north of the map: −26°F over 118 years
The coldest ground on the map lies that way, in the northeast corner and along the James at the north edge.
All of that holds best on still, clear nights. A deep arctic outbreak, like the one in February 1899 that took Forestburg 4 NNE to −46°F and Howard to −42°F, fills everything, bluff and bottom alike. The variety has to be hardy enough first. The site helps after that.
Mitchell, River Bluff Addition and Riverside
Mitchell, the Davison County seat, goes by the Palace City and is home to the Corn Palace and Dakota Wesleyan University. Downtown sits on flat ground at 1,306 feet and plans for −28°F, MFTC zone 4a, with a typical winter of −17°F. Within 3 miles the planning low runs from −32°F to −27°F. And the mildest ground on the whole map is in town: the flats 1 mile west-southwest of downtown and 1.7 to 1.9 miles south-southeast plan for −27°F.
The Mitchell station, 0.9 mile north-northeast of downtown, has a 1-in-30 number of −27°F, and the map gives that spot −28°F. The Mitchell airport station, 4.4 miles north of downtown, has a 1-in-30 number of −30°F, the same as the map gives it.
The bluffs along the James are the best fruit ground near town. The hillside 2.1 miles east-southeast of downtown, 80 feet above its floor on a 10 percent slope, plans for −30°F and reads 6°F warmer than downtown at bloom. The river bottom 2.8 miles east plans for −31°F and reads 8.8°F colder. West of downtown, the creek bottom 1.7 miles out reads 8.8°F colder too.
River Bluff Addition, 2.6 miles northwest of downtown, plans for −29°F and reads 2.8°F colder at bloom, and the low ground 0.9 mile north-northeast of it 8°F colder. Riverside, across the James 3.9 miles east-northeast of downtown, sits 90 feet above its floor. It plans for −29°F and reads 2.3°F warmer, and the slope half a mile west-northwest of it reads 5.6°F warmer.
Mount Vernon, Betts, Plankinton and Stickney
Mount Vernon, first called Arlandton and renamed in 1882, sits 11.8 miles west of downtown Mitchell at 1,408 feet. It plans for −30°F, MFTC zone 4a, right at the line with 3b, with a typical winter of −18°F, and reads 2.3°F colder than downtown Mitchell at bloom. Around it:
- Flats 1.7 miles south of town: −28°F
- Creek bottom 2.6 miles southwest: −33°F, 6.9°F colder
- Enemy Creek, at its bridge 4.4 miles south: −32°F, 6°F colder
Betts, between Mount Vernon and Mitchell, plans for −30°F and reads 2.8°F colder.
Plankinton, the Aurora County seat, is named for John Plankinton, a Milwaukee meatpacker and railroad official, and its wheat palace, opened in 1891, gave Mitchell the idea for the Corn Palace. The town sits at 1,525 feet and plans for −31°F, MFTC zone 3b, with a typical winter of −18°F, and reads 2°F colder than downtown Mitchell at bloom. It's flat country. Within 3 miles of town the planning low only runs from −32°F to −31°F. The spring layer shows more. The bottom 2.9 miles east-southeast of town and the low slope 1.9 miles north-northeast both read 7.6°F colder than downtown Mitchell, so I'd use whatever rise you've got for stone fruit.
South of Plankinton the land climbs. Stickney, at 1,643 feet, plans for −29°F (zone 4a), typical winter −16°F, and reads 1.7°F colder than downtown Mitchell at bloom. The bottoms about 2 miles west and southwest of it plan for −31°F to −32°F and read 6.7°F colder. Aurora Center, at 1,647 feet, plans for −29°F, and the ground on the south edge about 7 miles southeast of it −27°F.
Ethan, Dimock, Metzgerville and Hillside
Ethan, 11.6 miles south of downtown Mitchell at 1,345 feet, plans for −31°F, MFTC zone 3b, with a typical winter of −18°F, and reads 3.2°F colder than downtown at bloom. Within 3 miles the planning low runs from −34°F to −29°F.
- Flats 1.4 miles west: −29°F
- Bottom 2.9 miles east-southeast: −34°F
- Bottom 1.4 miles east-northeast: −32°F, 10°F colder than downtown Mitchell at bloom
- Toe slope 2.8 miles east: 1.6°F warmer than downtown Mitchell
Dimock, 5 miles south of Ethan, plans for −30°F (zone 3b, right at the line) and reads 2.8°F colder.
West of Ethan the land rises, and the upland around Metzgerville and Hillside is some of the mildest open country on the map. Metzgerville, at 1,608 feet, plans for −30°F and reads 4.3°F colder at bloom, but the hillside 1.4 miles east of it reads 2.4°F warmer. Hillside, at 1,635 feet, plans for −29°F (zone 4a) and reads 2.2°F colder. The upland west of them, around 1,680 to 1,690 feet, plans for −28°F. South of here our Wagner, Lake Andes and Platte map picks up.
Alexandria, Fulton, Emery and Farmer
Alexandria, the Hanson County seat, started out in 1879 as Clarksville and was renamed in 1885, after Alexander Mitchell. It sits 12.7 miles east-southeast of downtown Mitchell at 1,353 feet and plans for −32°F, MFTC zone 3b, with a typical winter of −19°F, and reads 2.1°F colder than downtown Mitchell at bloom. Within 3 miles the planning low runs from −35°F to −30°F. The toe slope 1.1 miles east-southeast of town and the creek bottom 2 miles south plan for −35°F and read 9.4°F colder. The ground 2.8 miles west, toward the James, plans for −30°F. The Alexandria station, at the west edge of town, has a 1-in-30 number of −31°F, the same as the map gives it.
Fulton, 5.3 miles north-northwest of Alexandria, plans for −31°F and reads 2.7°F colder. Emery, near the east edge, plans for −31°F and reads 2.4°F colder, but the bottoms within about a mile of town plan for −33°F to −34°F and read up to 11°F colder. Farmer plans for −30°F (zone 4a, right at the line). The bottom 2.4 miles north-northwest of it plans for −35°F.
It gets colder up the east side. Epiphany, 8.7 miles north of Farmer, plans for −34°F with a typical winter of −21°F, and its bloom reading, 5.4°F colder than downtown Mitchell, is the coldest of any named place. The low ground about 9 miles north of it, in the northeast corner, plans for −36°F, MFTC zone 3a. East toward Sioux Falls our Sioux Falls and the Big Sioux map picks up, and northeast toward Brookings the Brookings, Watertown and the Coteau map.
Rosedale, Rockport, Old Elm Spring and Oak Lane
Below Mitchell the James swings southeast past Millbrook, Rosedale and Rockport colonies to the Elm Spring colonies on the south edge. Its bottom drops to 1,196 feet, the lowest ground on the map, with bluffs 100 to 130 feet above it.
Rosedale Colony, on the toe of the slope at 1,251 feet, plans for −33°F, MFTC zone 3b, typical winter −20°F, and reads 1.3°F colder than downtown Mitchell at bloom. The bottom 0.3 mile north of it reads 10.4°F colder, and the hillside 1.7 miles west, 90 feet up, 7.3°F warmer. Rockport Colony, 3.4 miles south-southeast, plans for −33°F and reads 4.7°F colder. The hillside 0.9 mile south-southeast of it, 100 feet up, reads 8.4°F warmer.
Old Elm Spring Hutterite Colony sits 90 feet above its floor and reads 3.6°F warmer than downtown Mitchell at bloom, the best of any named place, though it plans for −31°F. North of it, the hillside 3.2 miles north-northwest, 130 feet up, reads 9.2°F warmer than downtown Mitchell, and the river bottom 1.3 miles from that hillside 11.4°F colder. Nearly 21°F apart on the same night. New Elm Spring Hutterite Colony plans for −32°F, and Oak Lane Hutterite Colony, right on its floor, −34°F. Along this stretch I'd put stone fruit on the bluffs and benches and nowhere near the bottom.
Letcher, Loomis, Cuthbert and Storla
North of Mitchell, Firesteel Creek runs east across the upper part of Davison County into Lake Mitchell. Firesteel, an early community, grew up on the creek after Herman Cady Greene and John Head settled there in 1871. On a point above the lake sits the Mitchell Prehistoric Indian Village, an earth lodge village whose people grew corn, beans, squash, sunflowers and tobacco.
The creek bottoms up here are frost pockets. At the Firesteel Creek bridge 1.9 miles southwest of Loomis the bottom plans for −32°F and reads 9.9°F colder than downtown Mitchell at bloom. Loomis plans for −30°F (zone 3b, right at the line) and reads 4.4°F colder.
Letcher, 14 miles north-northwest of downtown Mitchell, sits on a river bottom only 10 feet above its floor. It plans for −32°F, MFTC zone 3b, typical winter −19°F, and reads 4.4°F colder at bloom. Cuthbert, near the north edge, plans for −31°F and reads 4.5°F colder, with a bottom a mile southeast at −35°F. Storla plans for −31°F. East of the river, Plano and Farwell plan for −31°F and read about 4°F colder, while Upland Hutterite Colony, 70 feet above its floor, plans for −32°F and reads 2.4°F warmer.
The James comes in at the north edge in its coldest stretch. The bottom 6.4 miles north-northeast of Letcher plans for −35°F, MFTC zone 3a. North of here our Huron and the James map picks up.
Spring frost and bloom around Mitchell
The Mitchell airport station's median last 32°F frost, 1991 to 2020, is May 3, and its median first in fall is October 6, a frost free season of 156 days. That station sits on flat ground 4.4 miles north of downtown, and our spring layer reads it 2.9°F colder than downtown on a still bloom night. So in town I'd call May 3 the safe side. In the bottoms, which read 6°F to 11.5°F colder than downtown, plan on frost hanging on later.
Most towns here read 2°F to 5°F colder than downtown Mitchell at bloom, since town heat helps downtown and most of the others sit close to their floors. The bigger spread is between bottom and bluff. The bluffs 60 to 130 feet above the James read 5°F to 9.5°F warmer than downtown, and a hillside and the bottom below it can be 20°F apart on the same calm night.
So I'd put the early bloomers on the bluffs and rises. Apricots bloom first, so give them the highest, best drained slope you have, with a bottom below it to take the cold. Plums, cherries and peaches come next. Pears bloom early too, so keep them off low ground. Apples and applecrabs bloom later and can go lower, and so can the bush fruit. And look downhill. A shelterbelt or hedge or road grade across the slope below your trees dams the cold and backs it up into them, so leave a gap at the low end.
What the weather records say
The coldest reading in the long records around this map is −46°F, at the Forestburg 4 NNE station on February 9, 1899. Two days later Howard read −42°F, the Mitchell 2 N station −39°F and Alexandria −38°F. Then on February 2, 1905:
- Armour, just outside the map: −45°F
- Mitchell 2 N: −39°F
- Alexandria: −38°F again, still its record in 113 years
Since the 1995-96 winter the Alexandria station's coldest is −29°F, in that first winter. The records for the two Mitchell stations start later, in 2000 at the airport and 2004 in town. They've bottomed out at −28°F (the airport, December 18, 2016) and −24°F (in town, 2018-19). Neither record reaches back to February 1996, when the National Weather Service office in Sioux Falls lists −36°F at Mitchell on the 3rd.
USDA's 2023 map puts Mitchell (57301), Plankinton (57368) and Alexandria (57311) in zone 5a, −20°F to −15°F, by ZIP code. USDA's zones are built on the average of each winter's coldest night, about what our typical winter shows: −17°F in Mitchell, −18°F in Plankinton and −19°F in Alexandria. Ours is built on the bad night you plan for:
- MFTC zone 4a: Mitchell, Mount Vernon, Stickney and Hillside
- 3b: Plankinton, Alexandria, Ethan, Emery and Letcher
- 3a: the coldest bottoms and the northeast corner
After the 2023 map came out, Laura Edwards, the state climatologist, wrote for SDSU Extension that much of South Dakota moved one zone warmer and urged caution in trying new perennial plants.
What you can grow here
Winter does the first sort here. Everything we sell rated −40°F or colder has come through colder than every planning low on this map, and anything rated −35°F or colder clears all of it but the coldest bottoms and the northeast corner. The −30°F trees fit Mitchell and the milder ground. Nothing on our list rated −25°F or warmer has come through any ground on this map.
Mitchell and the milder ground, −27°F to −30°F
Mitchell (−27°F to −28°F), the upland west of Metzgerville and Hillside (−28°F), River Bluff Addition, Riverside, Stickney, Aurora Center and Hillside (−29°F), and Mount Vernon, Betts, Farmer, Loomis, Metzgerville and Dimock (−30°F). Everything rated −30°F or colder has come through all of it. At the −30°F towns it's right at the line, though, so I'd give those trees your best spot.
- Peaches: Contender, Blushingstar and Veteran (all −30°F), and Siberian C (−35°F), the hardiest peach we sell
- Apricots: Harlayne and Tomcot (−30°F) and Montana Mango (−35°F)
- Sweet cherries: Rainier (−30°F) and Lapins (−35°F)
- Plums: Stanley (−30°F) and Superior (−35°F), with Toka (−45°F), a good pollenizer for Superior
- Pears: Harrow Sweet (−30°F) and Bartlett (−35°F)
- Apples: Northern Spy (−30°F), Liberty (−35°F) and Honeycrisp (−45°F)
Plankinton, Alexandria and the middle of the map, −31°F to −32°F
Plankinton, Ethan, Emery, Fulton, Cuthbert, Storla, Farwell, Plano and Old Elm Spring (−31°F), Alexandria, Letcher, Phantom Lake and Upland Colony (−32°F), and most of the open country between them. I'd skip the −30°F trees here. The −35°F ones have come through all of it with room to spare.
- Peach: Siberian C
- Apricots: Montana Mango (−35°F), Sungold (−40°F) and Westcot (−45°F), on your highest ground
- Cherries: Lapins and Black Gold sweet cherries and Montmorency tart cherry (all −35°F), and Evan's Bali tart cherry (−45°F)
- Plums: Superior with Toka, and South Dakota and Pipestone (−40°F)
- Pears: Bartlett (−35°F), Flemish Beauty (−40°F) and Summercrisp (−45°F)
- Apples: Liberty (−35°F), Zestar!® and Sweet Sixteen (−40°F), and Honeycrisp and Haralson (−45°F)
Rosedale, Rockport, Epiphany and the cold bottoms, −33°F to −36°F
Rosedale and Rockport colonies (−33°F), Epiphany and Oak Lane (−34°F), the bottoms along the James and around Alexandria, Emery and Farmer (−33°F to −35°F), and the north edge and northeast corner (−35°F to −36°F). The −35°F trees have come through the −33°F and −34°F ground. They're right at the line on the −35°F bottoms and haven't come through −36°F, and there I'd stick with −40°F and hardier.
- Apricots: Sungold (−40°F), and Westcot and Morden 604 (−45°F), up on the bluffs
- Cherries: Meteor tart cherry (−40°F), Evan's Bali (−45°F) and Juliet dwarf cherry (−50°F)
- Plums: South Dakota and Pipestone (−40°F), Toka and Mount Royal (−45°F) and Brookred (−50°F)
- Pears: Summercrisp and Ure (−45°F) and Krasnobokaya (−50°F)
- Apples: Haralson and Honeycrisp (−45°F), and Wealthy and Prairie Sensation (−50°F)
- Applecrabs: Kerr and Chestnut (−50°F). If you only plant one tree in a bottom, I'd make it one of those.
Matching trees to the spring layer
Where your spot reads warmer than downtown Mitchell on the spring layer (the James bluffs, the slopes by Riverside, Rosedale, Rockport and Old Elm Spring), I'd call it ground for apricots, peaches, cherries and plums. Where it reads 5°F or more colder (the James bottom, Firesteel Creek, the creek bottoms around Ethan, Alexandria and Emery), plant apples, applecrabs and bush fruit. Honeyberry, Serviceberry and Consort black currant (all −50°F), Red Lake currant and Pixwell gooseberry (both −40°F), and Nova raspberry (−50°F). Most apples, pears and plums need a pollenizer blooming with them. Our pollination maps show the pairings.
Site, snow and roots
Plant on a rise or a slope, off the bottom. Check drainage first. Fill the planting hole with water, let it drain, fill it again, and if water's still standing the next day, plant on a low mound or pick another spot. Mitchell averages about 40.6 inches of snow a year, and snow that stays put is the best root cover there is. Where it blows off, mulch young trees before a cold snap. Water by drip, the only irrigation we advise for fruit trees. Paint young trunks with white latex paint against sunscald, and put 1/4 inch hardware cloth guards at least 2 feet high around them, nudged a couple of inches into the soil, to keep voles off.
Questions people ask
When is the last frost in Mitchell?
The Mitchell airport station's median last 32°F frost, 1991 to 2020, is May 3, and its median first fall frost is October 6, a frost free season of 156 days. In town May 3 is on the safe side. But the James and creek bottoms run 6°F to 11.5°F colder than downtown on a still spring night.
What growing zone is Mitchell, SD?
USDA's 2023 map puts Mitchell's 57301 ZIP in zone 5a, −20°F to −15°F. Our map has downtown Mitchell planning for −28°F, MFTC zone 4a, with a typical winter of −17°F. USDA's zone is built on an average winter. Ours is built on the bad night we plan for. Plankinton (−31°F) and Alexandria (−32°F) are MFTC zone 3b.
Can you grow peaches in Mitchell?
Yes. Downtown plans for −28°F, and Contender, Blushingstar and Veteran have come through −30°F, Siberian C −35°F. I'd plant them on a bluff that reads warm at bloom, like the one 2.1 miles east-southeast of downtown (6°F warmer), and not the James bottom half a mile below it (10.3°F colder). In Plankinton and Alexandria, stick with Siberian C.
Where are the frost pockets around Mitchell?
In the James and creek bottoms. On a still bloom night the James bottom 2.8 miles east of downtown reads 8.8°F colder than downtown, and Firesteel Creek at its bridge near Loomis 9.9°F colder. Down the James past Rosedale and Old Elm Spring it reads up to 11°F colder.
What fruit trees grow in Plankinton and Alexandria?
Plankinton plans for −31°F and Alexandria −32°F, both MFTC zone 3b, so I'd skip the −30°F trees. Siberian C peach, Lapins sweet cherry, Montmorency tart cherry, Montana Mango apricot, Superior plum, Bartlett pear and Liberty apple have come through −35°F, and Haralson and Honeycrisp −45°F.
Why is Mitchell milder than the country around it?
Town heat, worth about 2.5°F downtown on a still night, and station records that run milder in the middle of the map than to the north. Downtown plans for −28°F. The James bottom 2.8 miles east plans for −31°F, Alexandria −32°F and Epiphany −34°F.
Warmer spots, colder spots
Here's what to plan for at named places on the map, warmest first. Each one is the 1-in-30-year low for that spot. It's the cold hardiness calculator's number off the same weather stations, and then our microclimate model sharpens it for the ground right there. Zone means our MFTC zone, and that comes from the one bad night, not an average.
Runs warmer
Runs colder
How this map works
Every number on this map is a 30-year planning low, same as our cold hardiness calculator gives you. I build it from NOAA station records and lean it a little cold on purpose, then nudge it a degree or two for the ground right around you. The spring frost layer runs our whole terrain model, which follows cold air down the draws and into the bottoms. Plan with it but don't treat it like a promise. How long the cold hangs on matters, so do wind and soil and those warm spells in late winter.
If you want the physics of cold air, how I build the number, every terrain weight and where the model falls short, it's all on one page: how our microclimate maps work.
The weather stations behind it
These are the long record stations in and around this map, with each one's own numbers since the winter of 1995-96. The last column is the map's 30-year number right at the station. It won't match the station exactly, because it's a blend of the stations around it. That's how the calculator does it everywhere.
| Station | Elev (ft) | Winters | Coldest since 1995 | Average winter low | 1-in-30 low | Map here |
|---|
Source: NOAA records through ACIS, winters 1995-96 through 2025-26. What the "carried forward," "gaps filled" and AWOS rows mean is explained in how our microclimate maps work.
Take your spot to the calculator. Click your ground on the map and open the cold hardiness calculator right there. It'll show you every plant we grow that's come through that cold.
Open the cold hardiness calculator